Efficiency in Household Decision Making: Evidence from the Retirement Savings of U.S. Couples

This paper has been awarded the 2025 TIAA Paul A. Samuelson Award. Congratulations to our researchers!

Learn more

From  Taha Choukhmane, Lucas Goodman and Cormac O'Dea

Pareto Efficiency is a core assumption of most models of household decision-making. We test this assumption using a new dataset covering the retirement saving contributions of over a million U.S. individuals. While a vast literature has failed to reject household efficiency in developed countries, we find evidence of widespread inefficiency in our setting: retirement contributions are not allocated to the account of the spouse with the highest employer match rate. This lack of coordination cannot be explained by inertia, auto-enrollment, or simple heuristics. Instead, we find that indicators of weaker marital commitment correlate with the incidence of inefficient allocations.

Learn More about Retirement

Current Retirement projects from the Consumer Finance Initiative cover topics including Target Date Funds, retirement savings and portfolio choices, and racial gaps in retirement savings.  Find more Retirement research here.