What is a glass cliff?
A working definition from MIT Sloan
glass cliff (noun)
A situation in which women and other minority employees are preferentially appointed to leadership positions in times of crisis.
Data shows that companies are failing to retain and advance occupational minorities. Writing in MIT Sloan Management Review, Keith D. Dorsey, a managing partner at global executive search firm Boyden, examines one reason why: the “glass cliff” phenomenon. This occurs when women and other minorities are preferentially selected for leadership positions in times of upheaval, placing them at increased risk for failure.
One study found that poorly performing Fortune 500 companies were more likely to appoint a female CEO than those performing well. Another study found that boards were more likely to recruit female directors following decreased stock performance.
“In times of crisis, leaders — no matter who they are — tend to be seen as ineffective and part of the problem,” Dorsey wrote. When the leader is an occupational minority, any failure or lack of improvement tends to be blamed on their personal failings rather than the situation.
To avoid this outcome, organizations should fully analyze their current challenges and needs before selecting the appropriate leader to address them. With careful preparation and the right support system, glass cliffs can be opportunities for underrepresented groups to gain valuable experience and attain greater career success.
From glass ceilings to glass cliffs: A guide to jumping, not falling
Career
Women's Leadership Program
In person at MIT Sloan
Register Now
Workers need good jobs. The climate sector can help
The U.S. is experiencing a crisis around job quality. Emerging climate jobs can give workers a living wage, health care, and safe working conditions.
This Walmart executive runs on people power and consistent routines
In leading teams for Walmart, DoorDash, and CVS, Astha Purohit values a strong sense of ownership, shared purpose, and trust among collaborators.
4 developmental tasks you — and everyone else — will face in retirement
First: Deciding to retire.
This finance exec is a fan of nonlinear career paths
Former CFO Ellen Lederman talks career on- and off-ramps and the value of building on others’ experiences, as well as your own.
How assertive communication helped this M&A executive rise to the top
Clarisa Estol on taking responsibility for her own career resilience and championing a de-biased recruitment and hiring process.
The bottom-line benefits of second chance hiring
Kelly CEO Peter Quigley shares how hiring workers with criminal records can be good for business and beneficial for building community.
Gensler exec: ‘Amplify your impact as you advance your career’
Gensler global co-chair Diane Hoskins talks “focused relaxation” and finding her voice during a worldwide crisis.
How companies can use AI to find and close skills gaps
To train employees on digital skills, companies need precise insight into current workforce skills. Artificial intelligence can help.
Why this tech consultant and executive coach embraces being a B student
“We’re socialized from the time we’re children to be excellent at everything all the time — and it’s exhausting.”
Women’s career advice: Remember that exhaustion is not a yardstick for productivity
EzCater’s co-founder and former CEO on organizing priorities, forgiving your imperfections, and proactively looking for growth opportunities.